How would Becerra’s solar Power Hour actually work?
This is California Wire, a weekly newsletter from Jeff St. John on the state’s clean energy transition. Subscribe to get it weekly via Substack.
Hello, everyone! California Gov.-elect Xavier Becerra’s Power Hour plan is getting a ton of attention right now, so let’s dive into it.
During his campaign, Becerra said that if elected, he would institute a policy offering up to two hours of free electricity in the middle of each day, a move that his administration says could cut utility bills by about $1,000 a year. The proposal has won accolades from clean energy luminaries like former Michigan Gov. and Biden administration Energy Secretary Jennifer Granholm, former California Public Utilities Commissioner Cliff Rechtschaffen, and UC Santa Barbara professor and author Leah Stokes, who explained why it’s so exciting at last week’s Canary Live Bay Area event.
Free midday rates could encourage people to use more electricity at times when solar power is abundant, so much so that it’s being increasingly curtailed, especially during mild spring and autumn days, often driving wholesale power prices into negative territory. That makes free power “actually possible in California,” said Claudine Custodio, regulatory director for the West at nonprofit Vote Solar.
But the devil is in the details, so utility rate design experts have been busy figuring out how it could actually work.
The first step is to “make it as simple and easy to understand as possible,” said Michael Colvin, director of regulatory and legislative affairs at the Environmental Defense Fund. While at the California Public Utilities Commission (CPUC), he helped design the time-of-use rates now used by the state’s big three investor-owned utilities, which charge more for power during the evening, when solar production fades and the state’s grid faces its greatest stress.
That rate switch has been complicated enough for customers, Colvin said. Matching rates to seasonal shifts in those peak power costs “would be a messaging nightmare.”
The same lesson should apply to Power Hour. Even if wholesale power is cheaper in the spring and fall than it is in the winter or summer, the hours of free electricity should stay the same, he said.
That brings up another issue: Just because there’s excess solar power on California’s grid doesn’t make it free to deliver to households. Wholesale power costs make up only about one-third of the typical rates charged by California’s big utilities. The majority of monthly bills goes toward covering fixed costs — mainly those associated with building and maintaining power grids.
Cutting customers’ bills to zero cents per kilowatt-hour for two hours a day will force utilities to increase rates at other times or find alternative ways to make up for income they’d lose during that period. And Becerra has made clear that his plan can’t push total costs higher.
That could be why Becerra has proposed starting by offering free electricity during certain hours only to families eligible for CARE (California Alternate Rates for Energy) and FERA (Family Electric Rate Assistance). Every utility regulated by the CPUC must provide these discount programs for income-qualified households, and the money to pay for those discounts is collected from charges on all other customers’ bills.
It would be smart to avoid a complicated utility rate restructuring so that Power Hour can happen right away, said Rebecca Lee, the director of Western U.S. government affairs for NRG Energy and a former CPUC rate analyst. She noted that current legislation authorizing CARE and FERA may give the CPUC some flexibility to move money around to cover additional Power Hour costs. “You could create a sub-option within CARE where you have more flexibility to use the CARE subsidy in a time-differentiated way,” she said.
Furthermore, to be effective, Power Hour will need to be paired with programs that help customers make the most use of free midday electricity, Lee said — even when they’re not at home.
The CPUC’s Energy Savings Assistance Program already gives CARE customers energy-efficiency assistance, Colvin said. The program could offer free smart thermostats that can be programmed to activate during those free midday hours and precool residences, so when people get home later, they don’t need as much air conditioning. Smart plugs and programmable appliances could also be helpful.
Batteries are a lot more expensive than smart thermostats, but can sock away a lot more free midday power, Custodio said. Expanding virtual power plants like the currently underfunded Demand Side Grid Support program could make batteries more affordable for a broader set of customers, especially in parts of the Central Valley and Southern California, where most of the state’s utility-scale solar is, and where lower-income households face high summer utility bills.
So could allowing customers to use plug-in batteries, much as California has done for balcony solar systems, said Nick Josefowitz, founder and chief executive of energy-affordability nonprofit Permit Power. “Many low-income families don’t use that much power in the middle of the day when Becerra would make it free,” he said.
My take
This to-do list only scratches the surface of what the Becerra administration, California lawmakers, the CPUC, the California Energy Commission, and both investor-owned and publicly owned utilities will need to figure out to make Power Hour a success. Utilities may eventually have to upgrade their rickety billing software systems to support a free rate during those hours, and find workarounds in the meantime, like sending people rebate checks. That could get things up and running while the CPUC works on a more permanent plan, perhaps through individual utility rate proceedings or the commission’s advanced electric rate design rulemaking.
In the long run, if the Becerra administration wants to “spread out demand instead of concentrating it during the traditional peak hours in the late afternoon and evening,” as it states on its Power Hour page, it will want to pursue a wide range of ideas for getting people to use more electricity when it’s both cheap and clean. After all, the broader objective of California energy policy is to, “as a society, use up all the renewables we have,” Lee said.
What else I’m watching
Two different reports have come out this week with two very different assessments about how on track California is to meeting its emissions-reduction goals.
The “California Green Innovation Index” from Next 10 casts a fairly rosy light on the state’s climate progress to date, pointing to more than 2 million EVs on the road, more than 20 gigawatts of battery storage, and solar power outgenerating fossil gas. All told, California saw a 3.9% drop in greenhouse gas emissions from 2023 to 2024, the year with the most recent data available, marking the largest annual decrease outside the recession years of 2008–09 and 2019–20.
That’s good news. But the state is still falling short on meeting its 2030 goal of cutting greenhouse gas emissions by 40% below 1990 levels by 2030. “The Becerra era begins with real climate momentum, but progress isn’t guaranteed,” said Stephanie Leonard, the group’s director of research.
Meanwhile, a new report from the Environmental Working Group paints a more dire picture, stating that hitting California’s goal of carbon-free energy by 2045 will require adding about 8 GW of clean generating capacity per year.
But California has averaged bringing online only about 3 GW per year of utility-scale renewables and 1.5 GW of rooftop solar, EWG’s analysis finds. Nor do the state’s current buildout plans match the scale of growth required. The answer to this shortfall, according to report author Richard McCann, a founding partner at consultancy M.Cubed, is to dramatically increase rooftop solar.
McCann and other supporters of rooftop solar argue that California’s legacy net-metering programs have been an overall benefit to the state’s utility customers. Utilities and the CPUC’s Public Advocates Office, by contrast, claim that previous rooftop solar programs have just shifted costs to other customers. We’re not going to resolve that fight in this newsletter. But with California lagging in its utility-scale clean energy buildout, it’s hard to see how expanding opportunities for distributed solar would hurt.
Wildfire reform, no closer
The prospect of California leaders quickly taking up a last-minute utility-wildfire-liability-reform package seems to be fading (to get up to speed on the current quagmire, check out my newsletter from a couple of weeks ago).
Outgoing Gov. Gavin Newsom told Politico in an interview at the COP31 annual climate conference in Turkey that he expects “when the Legislature convenes in January, they’ll move very quickly,” implicitly kiboshing utilities’ hopes for a deal in the waning weeks of 2027.
Newsom could call a special session of the state legislature in December, but that would put lawmakers in an awkward position. “We see an uphill battle to striking meaningful alignment with the legislature in December with the lack of incentive from the legislature to effectively ‘front-run’ Governor-elect Becerra’s policy agenda,” Julien Dumoulin-Smith, a power, utilities, and clean energy equity analyst at investment firm Jefferies, wrote in a statement this week.
California’s year-round solar power glut
Getting back to Power Hour: NRG Energy’s Lee offered Canary Media a helpful visual aid to illustrate the fact that while the solar power surplus on California’s grid may vary greatly from season to season, it still makes midday grid power a lot cheaper than overnight grid power, no matter what month it is. The chart shows the averaged-out price of power throughout 2024 and 2025 across every hour of the day from a typical pricing node in Southern California Edison territory. According to Lee, this pretty clearly demonstrates that solar power is still cheap enough to be worth offering for free between 10 a.m. and 2 p.m., even if it happens to be cloudy outside.
One more thing
It’s been raining for days now, so we’re keeping our walks with Lily to a minimum. (If we can get her into her tartan raincoat, I’ll definitely share a photo.) But during a break in the weather, my wife and I did manage to get Lily out to Point Isabel, her happy place, where she at least briefly considered hopping into the slightly choppy waters of the San Francisco Bay before turning around. (Notice the city skyline on the horizon!)
Oh, and a quick note: I’ll be taking next week off for the Thanksgiving holiday. I’m looking forward to spending time with family and friends, and I hope you get to do the same. See you in December!
Jeff St. John is chief reporter and policy specialist at Canary Media. He covers innovative grid technologies, rooftop solar and batteries, clean hydrogen, EV charging, and more.
read next
-
-
-
-
Virtual power plants
New net-zero community will become Michigan’s first virtual power plant