Why tribal rights have become key to the energy permitting debate
For months, the climate world and the broader Democratic coalition have argued over whether the sweeping bipartisan permitting reform bill will be good or bad for the energy transition. But inside the Senate, which just passed the legislation by a 62–33 vote, concerns about tribal sovereignty overshadowed the debate over emissions — and now are likely to influence negotiations in the House, too.
While tribal nations have sovereignty over development within their reservation boundaries, any development on sacred sites and cultural resources beyond those boundaries is subject to a special review under the 1966 National Historic Preservation Act. That law requires federal agencies to consult with tribes, but not to win their consent.
Large-scale energy projects, including the 550-mile SunZia transmission line that carries wind power from New Mexico to Arizona and California, have previously drawn pushback from tribes despite the federal government engaging in these NHPA reviews. Some influential tribal organizations believe that the proposed changes to the NHPA under the permitting bill would infringe on their sovereignty — and water down the already imperfect government-to-government consultation process.
“Tribes are sovereign, and that does mean that they need to be able to have a meaningful say in the pretty rare instances where a development might impact an important historical or cultural site that is not on their reservation lands,” said Julian Brave NoiseCat, a member of the Canim Lake Band Tsq̓éscen of the Secwépemc Nation in British Columbia as well as an author and Oscar-nominated filmmaker who previously worked at the climate group 350.org.
These concerns took center stage as the Senate debated the bill, which analysts widely expect would benefit both clean energy and fossil fuels. Several large environmental groups have come out against the legislation over fears that it will increase planet-warming emissions, but the clean energy industry and some decarbonization advocates see the changes as essential for the energy transition.
In the end, the bill’s initial NHPA language was amended in response to concerns over sections that weakened tribal consultation and allowed for Interior Department oversight of Tribal Historic Preservation Offices. A bipartisan amendment that would have further strengthened tribal consultation on permitting, negotiated by Senate Indian Affairs Committee Chair Sen. Lisa Murkowski (R-Alaska) and Vice Chair Sen. Brian Schatz (D-Hawaii), failed following a last-ditch attempt by Sen. Jeff Merkley (D-Ore.) to scuttle the bill due to a host of criticisms.
As of Friday, many tribal organizations, including the National Congress of American Indians and the National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers, remain opposed to the bill.
“We urge the House to listen to Tribal Nations and reject this bill,” NATHPO executive director Ira Matt, who is Séliš and a citizen of the Confederated Salish and Kootenai Tribes, said in a statement released on Thursday night. “Congress should start over, consult directly with Tribal Nations, and address the causes of permitting delays while protecting Native places.”
Tribal issues are likely to loom large over the debate in the House, too, where the bill will presumably face opposition from progressive Democrats who take issue with its environmental rollbacks. But the bill’s supporters are also pressuring representatives to act before the clock runs out on this session of Congress, making the odds of passing any substantive amendments — like the ones proposed in the Senate — slim.
Still, not all tribal organizations oppose the current bill. Some see it as an opportunity to further develop their own energy sovereignty, including with renewables. The National Tribal Energy Association, a trade group, wrote to Congress on Nov. 5 in support of key provisions in the bill that the group said would “streamline infrastructure deployment across Indian Country, and unlock Tribal energy potential.”
“We were compelled to point out that there are positive provisions specifically for tribes that want to develop energy on their lands that they control,” said Daniel Cardenas, NTEA’s CEO and a member of the Hammawi Band of the Pit River Tribe. He added that much of the conversation about tribal sovereignty in the bill’s context has been filtered through environmental groups in a way that doesn’t fully represent the concept. “Who gets to define ‘tribal sovereignty’? Or, invariably, we talk about energy sovereignty. Who gets to define that? Is that coming from tribes, or is that coming from their allies or third parties?”
NoiseCat, who supports permitting reform, added that the debate over the bill as it relates to tribal interests has been framed around an assumption that tribes are anti-development and “are always on the receiving end” of it, which he said “is just, in point of fact, not true.”
The Apsáalooke (Crow) Nation, which has long been a producer of coal, submitted a letter in support of the legislation on Oct. 23. “For too long, overlapping federal reviews, bureaucratic delays, and unpredictable permitting timelines have hindered investment in Indian Country,” wrote Frank White Clay, the tribe’s chair. The Apsáalooke’s coal production has declined since the 2024 closure of the Westmoreland mine, and the tribe is now seeking to expand hydroelectric energy amid a stalled wind farm proposal.
In the wake of the role that tribal interests played in the Senate negotiations, NoiseCat said he hopes it signals a shift away from the historic balance of power that’s been concentrated among climate and environmental groups, rather than tribes themselves. “We do not get more power by obfuscating the truth, by simply seeing tribes as the first environmentalists,” said NoiseCat. “We don’t actually reflect the reality, which is that tribes are complicated. They have complicated considerations on these things the way that frankly all Americans do.”
Julia Tilton is a reporter and multimedia producer at The Daily Yonder.