In the South, heat pumps are the secret to a more reliable grid
For many in North Carolina and Tennessee, 2022’s Winter Storm Elliott lives in infamy. Temperatures plunged well below freezing for days at a time, just as families were gathered at home for the Christmas holiday. The grid couldn’t keep up, and some 1.6 million households lost power in rolling blackouts in those two states alone.
Like Winter Storm Uri in Texas the year before, Elliott was generally understood as a problem of supply: Scores of power plants, mostly gas-burning, failed because of frozen equipment. To maintain future reliability during bitter cold weather, regulators recommended that utilities winter-proof their gas plants and diversify by building more power sources.
But the authors of a new report say that increasing supply isn’t the cheapest way to prevent future winter blackouts across the U.S. South. Instead, the best option is reducing demand — specifically, from the old-fashioned, energy-sucking electric resistance furnaces that are more common in this region of the country than any other.
“Across the 14 states that we looked at in this analysis, there are approximately 8 million households that essentially heat their house with an electric hair dryer,” said Alex Antal, a report co-author and principal at the Regulatory Assistance Project, a global clean energy nonprofit.
If these homes instead covered most of their heating needs with heat pumps, which are three times more efficient than electric resistance furnaces, it would drastically reduce systemwide electricity demand — and utility bills. In fact, the report finds that heat pump deployment in the region would save as much power as that produced by 100 “peaker” plants, which are dispatched only when demand climbs high enough and are among the most expensive units on the grid. Building and maintaining new plants to create the same amount of electricity would cost six to nine times more, the report concludes.
“Those power plants are otherwise sitting unused the rest of the year,” said Forest Bradley-Wright, a report co-author and the state and utility program director at the nonprofit American Council for an Energy Efficient Economy. Improving home-heating efficiency, he said, “avoids the need to build more power plants that we all have to pay for. That saves money for everyone.”
The households that install heat pumps would save the most. The report identifies homes best suited to do this: those that have outdated electric heaters and central air conditioning. It calculates the benefits for customers who invest in heat pumps — which both cool and heat homes — when their AC reaches the end of its useful life. It assumes the existing electric furnace will remain as a backup.
A whole-home heat pump on average costs about $560 more than a traditional whole-home air conditioner, according to the report. But because it’s so much more efficient, the heat pump will cut annual electricity bills by $250, and pay for itself in about three years. Over 15 years, the cumulative savings across the entire region are estimated at nearly $30 billion — compared with a total investment of about $4.8 billion.
Still, replacing appliances in millions of homes is easier said than done. While the opportunity is tremendous, Bradley-Wright said, “it’s going to require some policy action.”
That includes rebates to help cover the upfront cost of the new appliances. Such inducements are more important than ever, since Congress repealed tax credits for home energy-efficiency improvements. The cash back should be distributed not just directly to customers but also to contractors, who can then apply incentives at the point of sale. Such “upstream” inducements are vital for those households looking to quickly replace a broken AC in the dead of summer, say, who may not be aware of heat pumps. “For an individual in that situation,” said Bradley-Wright, “the choice needs to be available, and it needs to be easy to make.”
Another reform the report proposes is “inclusive utility investment,” in which a utility bears the up-front cost and households pay it back over time directly through their monthly bills. Versions of these programs are already in development or underway in Arkansas, Georgia, Kentucky, North Carolina, and Virginia, the report notes.
State utility commissions also have a role to play, the report says, by requiring utilities to invest in heat-pump deployment and other demand-side measures before resorting to pricey fossil fuel infrastructure.
As regulators evaluate long-term plans for how utilities will meet their future power needs, Bradley-Wright said, they should know: “It is an option to invest in these energy-efficiency programs as an alternative to building more expensive gas plants.”
Elizabeth Ouzts is a contributing reporter at Canary Media who covers North Carolina and Virginia.